Roving Thoughts archives

Looking back at the Spring 2014 anime season

As before, it's time for my usual retrospective look back at the season to see how well my final views match up with my early impressions and my midway views. Sort of as I did in my winter season retrospective, there's one show I'm ranking based on how much I'm enjoying it instead of how good I think it is (for everything else I think the two match up quite well).

Excellent:

• Ping Pong: This is the total surprise of the season for me, far more than I expected at the start of the season. My best description of it (borrowed from somewhere else) is that in the end it's a character piece carefully disguised as a sports story, and what a character piece it is. It is full of interesting real people and it covers its events with a beautifully understated touch. It is unafraid to show instead of tell and more than that, to show without jumping up and down to point out certain things. I found it powerful, affecting, and in the end touching.

  I liked the art style. I think it worked very well for how the story was told and how the story was told really helped the impact of the story.

  For more raving about how good Ping Pong is, see eg Bobduh (also).

• Knights of Sidonia: This is far from a flawless show but what elevates it here is that it absolutely nails a certain sense of atmosphere and ambivalence, and it's also a gorgeously SF show. I have come around to feeling that it absolutely needs to be in full CGI to work, not just for the stunningly well done battle scenes but also to draw a real distance between it and more 'anime' shows. The show is also genuinely well directed and well written, things that are unfortunately rare in anime. One sign of this is that it's willing to confidently depart from strict adherence to the manga storyline in order to improve the experience of the anime.

  (Some people feel that the large scale death rate in the show has caused this aspect of it to lose its impact. I disagree personally because I think that the show is going for a different sort of impact that is less about people dying and more about the massive death rate among the pilots.)

  I'm eagerly looking forward to its continuation in the fall.

  (See eg Bobduh's reaction to episode 11 for both praise and criticism.)

• Mushishi second season: This is still an excellent show, one that I think is better than Sidonia, but I've wound up feeling at a distance from it for most of the season. My current theory for why is that the episodes have lacked any sort of ongoing thread that runs between them. Sure, Ginko shows up in each of them, but for most episodes he's just been an oracular presence that solves problems or watches things happen; we haven't really been pulled into him emotionally. The exception that proves the rule is the marvelous episode 10, which is all about Ginko being unsettled and getting yanked around and us seeing the really weird side of the mushi.

  To put it one way, Mushishi has been great to watch but Sidonia has affected me when I watch it.

  (Mushishi was unfortunately hit with production delays that pushed back episodes 11 and 12 to its fall season continuation. Some rumours say that these are more plot and Ginko-heavy episodes; if they'd aired this season I might well have a much stronger opinion of Mushishi overall, based on my reaction to episode 10.)

Plain good fun:

• Hitsugi no Chaika: This wrapped up its first big arc with a nice big bang and a well done pivot to move the overall story forward. It continues to be a solid show with competence all around in its execution and I'm quite looking forward to the second season.

  (I have little to say here because this is effectively a midseason pause instead of anything more climactic. Of course the show is executing a midseason story pivot now; it was about time if things weren't going to drag.)

Relatively ordinary:

• Ryuugajou Nanana no Maizoukin: This wound up being a perfectly competent and decently interesting show with some interesting and intriguing characters. It's just not particularly memorable as these shows go because it's not particularly exceptional. Tensai is the best and most interesting character, with Juugo second.

• JoJo's Bizarre Adventure - Stardust Crusaders: I've continued to watch this basically as a comedy and it's continued to deliver that way. Things have stayed absurd and crazy and there have been some nice moments. I have no particularly deep emotional engagement with anyone in the show the way I have in every show from Chaika on up.

This season has turned out to be excellent, with several shows that are basically certain to rank highly in my eventual 'Best N in 2014' entry. While I'm disappointed with the failure of a few shows, this is much better than I expected at the start of the season; both Sidonia and especially Ping Pong turned out to be far more powerful shows than I anticipated.

(Looking back at my early Ping Pong impressions kind of makes me laugh now. And it's not that the show drastically improved over the course of its run. Its excellence was there from the start but I didn't trust the show to sustain it all the way through, so I was cautious.)

Checking in on the Spring 2014 anime season midway through

It's time for the usual midway check in on my early impressions of this season and as usual, it's a bit delayed. The headline news is that I've wound up feeling that this season is a pretty strong one, although I've also wound up dropping a number of shows.

Things I'm still watching:

• Mushishi second season: Either I have rosy memories of the first season or this season is tilting much more towards horror than the first season did. Whichever it is, the show still has Mushishi's deft and understated touch. And it's made me genuinely laugh.

• Ping Pong: What makes me so enthused about Ping Pong is that it's mostly doing a sort of story and exploring a collection of characters that I haven't really seen before in sports shows. Pretty much everyone both feels human and is interesting. I find the stylistic animation mostly just interesting, although I do think it helps the story and helps things stand out.

• Knights of Sidonia: If I had to describe this in one word I'd call it relentless; in animated form the show has acquired a visceral punch that the manga lacked for me. The battles are not soaring action affirmations but claustrophobic, tense exercises in people being all too human, things that you dread instead of looking forward to.

  (This is not as uncomfortable as, say, RideBack, but it is not exactly pleasant and cheerful.)

• Hitsugi no Chaika: This has slowed down some from the early episodes but it's staying solid and interesting, and it keeps pushing the plot forward at a decent pace. I'm glad that it's getting a second season. And as they say, 'Chaika a cute'.

  (Plus, casting all your magic with giant sniper rifles is always amusing. Wands, pah.)

• Ryuugajou Nanana no Maizoukin: This was trucking along as an ordinary show and then episode 4 happened and made pretty much everyone much more interesting. The show hasn't always delivered since then but it has come through pretty regularly, so I'm happy.

• JoJo's Bizarre Adventure - Stardust Crusaders: It took a while for the show to really grow on me, but it has. JoJo's is plain flat out absurd, crazy, and over the top and I just roll with it on those terms and enjoy the spectacle. I suppose what I'm saying here is that it's really a comedy.

Dropped:

• Haikyuu!!: This is a perfectly good sports show with perfectly good animation, characters, and so on. It's just not exceptional enough to overcome the fact that I generally don't get really enthused about straightforward sports shows, so I took the end of a recent storyline as a good point to stop watching.

• Soredemo Sekai wa Utsukushii: Despite everything nice I said about it in my initial impressions it turned out that I wasn't all that taken with the show after all. When it hit my least favorite manga storyline at episode 4 I found myself with no motivation to keep watching.

Now declared as misses:

• Captain Earth: I patiently gave this seven episodes to do anything sufficiently interesting and coherent and it didn't. It doesn't help that the show is periodically wince-inducingly clumsy and stupid (cf).

• Mekakucity Actors: This is basically the same as with Captain Earth. There is probably more here in the show than with CE (and certainly less stupidity), but the slow pace and the obscurity irritated me. I likely gave the show too many chances given my previous standard of 'stop promising, start delivering'.

• Black Bullet: After three episodes I concluded that this was just a typical light novel adaptation that had managed some flashes of being good. This was not enough to continue watching it.

  (It does have one of the better opening songs of the season, though.)

• Mahouka Koukou no Rettousei: I came to my senses immediately after writing my initial impressions and never watched any more. From all reports I made the right decision.

Six shows, with three of them being solidly good, is enough to make me happy about this season.

Sidebar: My favorite OP songs of the season

For my tastes, Knights of Sidonia first, Black Bullet a relatively distant second, and then Ping Pong. Nothing else really ranks, sadly including Mushishi (the first season's OP is great although somewhat creepy if you listen to the lyrics, but I don't like this season's OP at all and always skip it). After some qualms the full version of the Sidonia OP has been growing on me.

As far as EDs go, you can't really top JoJo's.