Roving Thoughts archives

In Memoriam: Looking back at the Spring 2006 anime season (part 1)

In the spring of 2006, I'd reached a point where I felt I had things to say about anime but I didn't quite feel like running my own blog for it for various reasons (despite already having a technical blog). A friend I knew online very generously offered to let me write guest posts on his blog and I decided that my first post would be a summary of the season's episodes that I'd seen so far. I wrote up my views but for various (bad) reasons I sat on my post and didn't actually publish it on my friend's blog right away. I more or less had time to hesitate and get up my courage, right?

Then my friend Gregory Blake died. Well. So much for that.

In the end it wouldn't be until 2009 that I started writing about anime stuff again. However, I am an inveterate electronic packrat so I never threw away that post about the start of the Spring 2006 season, even though it was never going to see the light of day after Gregory's death. For various reasons I've decided to dust it off, reformat it slightly, and run it here, ten years and change later.

If you read through my list of shows below and remember the spring season of 2006, you may notice an elephant (not) in the woodpile. Therein hangs a tale, and since this entry is already long enough I have put it in part 2 of my story.

(For the really curious, my original HTML file, untouched since May 14th 2006, is here.)

My Spring 2006 brief impressions (all text below is from 2006)

Some brief capsule summaries of my views on this season's new shows, because I feel like running my keyboard off and gregory has generously given me a platform to do it from. I'm not going to try to describe the shows (especially in one sentence); look them up in the usual set of places. If I don't mention it, either I haven't seen it yet or I'm not watching it at all for various reasons.

Rating scheme: how eagerly I am looking forward to the next episode, from +3 ('must have right now') to -3. Because I am a fan, I watch down to -1 or -2, depending on how busy I am. Ratings are pretty much relative, since they depend on what else is coming out at the same time.

• The Third - Aoi Hitomi no Shoujo (1-2): +3

  Ass-kicking female protagonist plus sardonic sidekick plus mysterious goings on equals WIN. As usual, a show that I think is good is getting fansubbed only slowly.

• Black Lagoon (1-3): +2

  Modern piracy has never looked quite this stylish; the over the top take on the violence fits in.

• Air Gear (1-6): +2

  Generic but well executed 'sports' anime; empty calories, but tasty and I keep coming back for another bite. I don't even mind the crazed goofyness of the sport.

• Zegapain (1-4): +1

  Giant robots are not usually my thing, but this is well animated, laced with lots of mysteries, and things keep happening.

• xxxHOLIC (1-5): +1

  So far mostly a charming tour through the supernatural.

• Ergo Proxy (1-9): +1

  A stylish future plus a bunch of mysteries, but it may be about to start explaining things (which is the doom of many an otherwise good show).

• TOKKO (1-2): +1

  I am a sucker for supernatural mysteries mixed with action; I could live without the fanservice.

• Tale of Saiunkoku (1): +1

  I don't mind ancient China (with the serial numbers filed off) and so far all of the protagonists are interesting (and some are spunky).

• Higurashi no Naku Koro ni (1-5): +1

  Supernatural horror/mystery mixed with harem game, with ordinary animation. The horror aspects are unusually well done, and I never know what's going to happen next.

• Simoun (1-2): +1

  The world setup is intriguing, but it remains to be seen where the anime will go with it; the plot and action have barely gotten off the ground. This would be a +0 except that I'm hoping it goes somewhere cool, and soon.

• Yume Tsukai (1-3): +0

  A lighthearted show about hunting down bad dreams. So far the formula is charming instead of tiring.

• RAY the animation (1-5): +0

  The adventures of a very peculiar surgeon. Well animated but contains a number of over the top elements that make me twitch, and may drive me away in the long run.

• Makai Senki Disgaea (1-4): +0

  Redeemed from a lower rating by not taking itself seriously. It's goofy and amusing, but very definitely empty calories.

• Tsubasa Chronicles Second Season (1-2): +0

  More of the same of the first season. I wish they'd hurry up with the real plot, although that's unlikely since this has the stately pace of a magical girls' show (substituting feather of the plot arc for monster of the week).

• Good Witch Of The West (1-2): -1

  A semi fantasy setting that is over-supplied with girls with robust glowing cheeks. I'm not sure where this is going and I'm not sure I'm interested in finding out, partly because it seems to be rather shoujo.

• Utawarerumono (1-3): -1

  There is nothing wrong with this anime; it's just failed to really engage my interest after three episodes. Some of the characters are a little too generic, too.

• Kiba (1-3): -2

  Pretty much a paint by numbers action anime, complete with the moody misunderstood protagonist who turns out to be really good with an important power.

• .Hack//Roots (1): -3

  Dropping mysterious hints in the first episode does not equal actually creating any interest, at least for me.

• Soul Link (1): -3

  This show wears its panties on its sleeve practically from the opening scene. Not particularly well animated, far too generic, and much too much fanservice.

Overall this seems like a relatively ordinary (or even weak) season. No show really makes me sit up with enthusiasm; there's no Mushishi or Noein. The Third is closest, but it probably would have been only a +1 or so in January.

How changing times can change our interpretation of what we see

Through a complicated chain of conversation, I recently wound up watching Digibro's "10 Killer Cuts in Evangelion Ep. 1" (via). Starting at 03:04 in that video, Digibro discusses one of his choices and, well, let me show you what startled me here with a frame from Digibro's video:

(full-sized, and Digibro primarily discusses this scene assuming that they are special sci-fi glasses)

According to his MAL profile, Digibro was born in 1991, which means that he probably first saw Neon Genesis Evangelion in the late 00s or maybe even in this decade. Even in the late 00s, glasses with electronic displays were not a particularly extreme idea and they'd probably shown up in a number of 00s anime shows, as well as being demonstrated and talked about in real life. By this decade, of course, the technology was far enough along that Google Glass could be offered as a high-end consumer item. Someone watching anime today could reasonably 'read' (aka interpret) a scene like this as showing such fancy smart glasses in action.

But Neon Genesis Evangelion was made in 1995 and first seen then, when even the idea of such glasses was relatively far out of the mainstream (much less the real-world technology). Almost no one seeing Neon Genesis Evangelion in 1995 would have read this scene as showing a futuristic heads-up display instead of being the reflection of the giant display screens on Gendo's mundane sunglasses, and it's very likely that the mundane explanation is what was intended by Gainax; otherwise they probably would have been far more explicit about showing us that Gendo's glasses were very special in both this scene and others.

Times have changed, though. A reading that was obvious in 1995 is no longer obvious now; the environment that we the audience exist in has changed our assumptions about what we see. And if smart glasses wind up becoming common, the 'smart glasses' reading will only become more and more the likely assumption of future audiences. They will have to be explicitly reminded that although Neon Genesis Evangelion is futuristic, it was created in the past and so its vision of the future does not match reality.

All of this makes me think, primarily about hidden assumptions.

I'm sure that Neon Genesis Evangelion is not the only show affected by being watched well after its creation and in a different environment, with an audience that makes different assumptions about 'obvious' things that we're seeing. Sometimes what we don't get in such shows is obvious and clearly out of place (which can be interesting), but sometimes it's not at all; our assumptions that we understand what we're seeing and are correctly interpreting it are just silently off.

(There are other little elements in Neon Genesis Evangelion that are quietly drifting out of place. One that comes to mind is how the cellphones are apparently there mostly just for voice calls.)

PS: Making assumptions is both necessary and assumed by the show's creators. One of the purposes of putting in familiar things, using familiar settings, and so on is that you can rely on the audience to understand them without having to take the time to explain them; instead you only have to cover any deviations from the normal (or from genre cliches that the audience will also assume).

Where I think each Pure Illusion world comes from in Flip Flappers

(There are going to be massive spoilers here for Flip Flappers, and of course this is speculation.)

At this point it seems pretty clear that some or many settings (or worlds) in Pure Illusion are not arbitrary but instead come from something or someone (or maybe in some cases represent things). So here are my theories about the source of the main worlds from each episode so far, up through episode 8 (at the moment).

• episode 1: tentatively Cocona herself. The world is frozen over but the sun comes up when Cocona moves herself to action, and it feels a quite Cocona-thematic setting in retrospect (well, Cocona as she is at the start of Flip Flappers).

• episode 2: Uexküll and the insides of the school's roof cleaning system.

• episode 3: Unknown. An interesting speculation would be that it's Papika.
  Update: it's from Sayuri.
• episode 5: Unknown. If you want to attribute episode 3's setting to Papika, I'd turn around and attribute this one to Cocona, as then they make a thematic pair (and say some interesting things).

  Update: it's probably Yayaka.

• episode 6: Iroha Irodori, of course. Even the Pure Illusion world they're in before they enter what is either her past or her mind is made in the colours and style of her paintings.

• episode 7: I feel it's unknown, although you could argue that it's Cocona again. If it is Cocona, it means that two fragments/amorphous have been recovered from Cocona-based worlds (one from ep 1, by Cocona, and one here, by Yayaka's team). I'm willing to believe this, as Cocona is clearly something special.

• episode 8: TT-392, who we know has a human or at least biological brain inside its chassis (seen in episode 1 and a couple of times since).

My overall view is that not all Pure Illusion worlds are neatly tied into the cast, so I think that the PI worlds in 3 and 5 are not due to anyone or anything we've seen. As far as episode 7 goes, my theory is that the PI setting there was originally something else (and from someone else), but it was basically hijacked by Cocona falling into it with unresolved issues; her presence warped it into something that reflected her worries.

(This entry may get updated to add more episodes.)

Update:

• episode 9: likely Yayaka; all the signs seem to point that way.

Update: I wrote a part 2 about new information on episode 3 that was revealed in episode 11, a strong theory about episode 5 from Emily Rand, more argument about episode 9, and a general wrapup in which I conclude that we aren't going to find any more good evidence in the show.